Over 300 Lightning Deals on Now plus FREE Discreet Shipping!

Small Anal Plugs

176AE      Beginner’s Purple Mini Ripple Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
176AE Beginner’s Purple Mini Ripple Plug Sold Out - $ 10.95 $ 21.95
+ Quick View
1851M      Chromed Steel Light Weight Ruby Red Crystal Tipped Butt Plug, Small - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
1851M Chromed Steel Light Weight Ruby Red Crystal Tipped Butt Plug, Small $ 20.95 $ 39.95
+ Quick View
1852M      Chromed Steel Light Weight Pink Crystal Tipped Butt Plug, Small - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
1852M Chromed Steel Light Weight Pink Crystal Tipped Butt Plug, Small $ 20.95 $ 39.95
+ Quick View
1882P      Anal Anchor, Neon Purple - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
1882P Anal Anchor, Neon Purple Sold Out - $ 9.95 $ 19.95
+ Quick View
220M      Black Silicone Mini Anal Plug with Pink Crystal Base - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
220M Black Silicone Mini Anal Plug with Pink Crystal Base $ 23.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View
221M      Black Silicone Mini Anal Plug with Emerald Crystal Base - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
221M Black Silicone Mini Anal Plug with Emerald Crystal Base $ 23.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View

222M      Black Silicone Mini Anal Plug with Sapphire Blue Crystal Base - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
222M Black Silicone Mini Anal Plug with Sapphire Blue Crystal Base $ 23.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View
2284AE      The Cone Mini Silicone Anal Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2284AE The Cone Mini Silicone Anal Plug $ 11.95 $ 22.95
+ Quick View
2284AE      The Cone Mini Silicone Anal Plug <b>DEAL FRENZY</b> - Sub-Shop.comDeal FRENZY - 1
2284AE The Cone Mini Silicone Anal Plug DEAL FRENZY $ 8.95 $ 22.95
+ Quick View
2287P      Ass Teazer Silicone Anal Plug - Sub-Shop.comButt Plug - 1
2287P Ass Teazer Silicone Anal Plug $ 14.95 $ 28.95
+ Quick View
2288P      Silicone Starter Anal Plug - Sub-Shop.comButt Plug - 1
2288P Silicone Starter Anal Plug $ 14.95 $ 28.95
+ Quick View
2304HS   Shaped Prostate Black Anal Plug w/Perineum Male G-Spot Stimulator - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys
2304HS Shaped Prostate Black Anal Plug w/Perineum Male G-Spot Stimulator $ 10.95 $ 19.95
+ Quick View

2307HS    Chrome and Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Diamond Crystal - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2307HS Chrome and Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Diamond Crystal $ 22.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View
2309HS    Chromed Steel Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Fuchsia Crystal - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2309HS Chromed Steel Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Fuchsia Crystal $ 22.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View
2309HS    Chromed Steel Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Fuchsia Crystal  <b>DEAL FRENZY</b> - Sub-Shop.comDeal FRENZY - 1
2309HS Chromed Steel Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Fuchsia Crystal DEAL FRENZY $ 17.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View
2311HS    Chromed Steel Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Amethyst Crystal - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2311HS Chromed Steel Crystal Anal Plug, Small Plug, Amethyst Crystal $ 22.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View
2335P      Basix Beginner Butt Plug, Black - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2335P Basix Beginner Butt Plug, Black $ 5.95 $ 10.95
+ Quick View
2336P      Basix Beginner Butt Plug, Pink - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2336P Basix Beginner Butt Plug, Pink $ 5.95 $ 10.95
+ Quick View

2346P    Fantasy X-Tensions Extreme Enhancer with Anal Plug - Sub-Shop.comCock Cage - 1
2346P Fantasy X-Tensions Extreme Enhancer with Anal Plug $ 17.95 $ 32.95
+ Quick View
2367P    Icicles Glass Big Black Butt Plug - Sub-Shop.comButt Plug - 1
2367P Icicles Glass Big Black Butt Plug $ 23.95 $ 42.95
+ Quick View
2374AE      Medium Black Anal Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2374AE Medium Black Anal Plug $ 13.95 $ 24.95
+ Quick View
2390HS      Small Gold Steel Butt Plug with Diamond Crystal Tip - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys
2390HS Small Gold Steel Butt Plug with Diamond Crystal Tip $ 23.95 $ 44.95
+ Quick View
2397P      Lil’ Popper Anal Pleaser - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2397P Lil’ Popper Anal Pleaser $ 12.95 $ 24.95
+ Quick View
2398P      Pull Plug Anal P-Spot Vibe - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
2398P Pull Plug Anal P-Spot Vibe $ 19.95 $ 38.95
+ Quick View

309P      Beginner's Butt Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
309P Beginner's Butt Plug $ 6.95 $ 12.95
+ Quick View
311P     Unisex Douche/Enema - Sub-Shop.comenema - 1
311P Unisex Douche/Enema $ 17.95 $ 34.95
+ Quick View
328P     Anal Fantasy Vibrating Perfect Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
328P Anal Fantasy Vibrating Perfect Plug $ 17.95 $ 34.95
+ Quick View
3304P      Jelly Anal Beads - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys
3304P Jelly Anal Beads $ 3.95 $ 7.95
+ Quick View
333P      Beginner's Prostate Stimulator - Sub-Shop.comProstate Stimulator - 1
333P Beginner's Prostate Stimulator $ 12.95 $ 24.95
+ Quick View
334P      One-Finger Fantasy G-Spot Butt Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
334P One-Finger Fantasy G-Spot Butt Plug $ 12.95 $ 24.95
+ Quick View

347P     Classix Prostate Stimulator - Sub-Shop.comProstate Stimulator
347P Classix Prostate Stimulator $ 10.95 $ 21.95
+ Quick View
349P      Basix Mini Butt Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
349P Basix Mini Butt Plug $ 5.95 $ 11.95
+ Quick View
370P      Double Trouble Anal Penetrator - Sub-Shop.comDildo - 1
370P Double Trouble Anal Penetrator $ 21.95 $ 42.95
+ Quick View
3789HS      Little Fox Mini Steel Butt Plug Tail - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
3789HS Little Fox Mini Steel Butt Plug Tail Sold Out - $ 28.95 $ 56.95
+ Quick View
501HS   Steel Mini Ribbed Foxy Pet Tail Cosplay Butt Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
501HS Steel Mini Ribbed Foxy Pet Tail Cosplay Butt Plug Sold Out - $ 26.95 $ 56.95
+ Quick View
6173MS     Anal Speculum for Medical Fetish OB/GYN Fantasy - Sub-Shop.comMedical Play - 1
6173MS Anal Speculum for Medical Fetish OB/GYN Fantasy $ 34.95 $ 69.95
+ Quick View

6863P      Two Finger Silicone Prostate Plug - Sub-Shop.comProstate Stimulator - 1
6863P Two Finger Silicone Prostate Plug $ 15.95 $ 29.95
+ Quick View
6863P      Two Finger Silicone Prostate Plug   <b>DEAL FRENZY</b> - Sub-Shop.comDeal FRENZY - 1
6863P Two Finger Silicone Prostate Plug DEAL FRENZY $ 13.95 $ 29.95
+ Quick View
6894MH      SomeBunny Luvs You Pink Silicone Bunny Tail Mini Plug - Sub-Shop.comButt Plug - 1
6894MH SomeBunny Luvs You Pink Silicone Bunny Tail Mini Plug $ 20.95 $ 39.95
+ Quick View
6900M      Straight to The Point Black Steel Anal Plug with T-Base - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
6900M Straight to The Point Black Steel Anal Plug with T-Base $ 26.95 $ 53.95
+ Quick View
6900M      Straight to The Point Black Steel Anal Plug with T-Base <b>DEAL FRENZY</b> - Sub-Shop.comDeal FRENZY - 1
6900M Straight to The Point Black Steel Anal Plug with T-Base DEAL FRENZY $ 21.95 $ 53.95
+ Quick View
6908R      Chrome Steel Ripple Butt Plug, Small, Purple Amethyst Gem - Sub-Shop.comButt Plug - 1
6908R Chrome Steel Ripple Butt Plug, Small, Purple Amethyst Gem $ 23.95 $ 46.95
+ Quick View

6912R      Puppy Love Mini Steel Heart Shaped Ruby Crystal Anal Plug - Sub-Shop.comAnal Toys - 1
6912R Puppy Love Mini Steel Heart Shaped Ruby Crystal Anal Plug $ 28.95 $ 55.95
+ Quick View
6916R      Midas Touch Steel Gold Tone Prostate Plug - Sub-Shop.comProstate Stimulator - 1
6916R Midas Touch Steel Gold Tone Prostate Plug $ 48.95 $ 89.95
+ Quick View
6931AR   Strict Penitentiary Fully Locking Steel Chastity Belt Harness Set with attached Steel Anal Dildo - Sub-Shop.comChastity - 1
6931AR Strict Penitentiary Fully Locking Steel Chastity Belt Harness Set with attached Steel Anal Dildo $ 231.95 $ 449.95
+ Quick View
6931AR   Strict Penitentiary Fully Locking Steel Chastity Belt Harness Set with attached Steel Anal Dildo <b>DEAL FRENZY</b> - Sub-Shop.comDeal FRENZY - 1
6931AR Strict Penitentiary Fully Locking Steel Chastity Belt Harness Set with attached Steel Anal Dildo DEAL FRENZY $ 174.95 $ 449.95
+ Quick View
6940AR      Locking Steel Female Chastity Belt with Removable Steel Plug - Sub-Shop.comChastity - 1
6940AR Locking Steel Female Chastity Belt with Removable Steel Plug $ 185.95 $ 454.95
+ Quick View
6940AR      Locking Steel Female Chastity Belt with Removable Steel Plug <b>DEAL FRENZY</b> - Sub-Shop.comDeal FRENZY - 1
6940AR Locking Steel Female Chastity Belt with Removable Steel Plug DEAL FRENZY $ 159.95 $ 454.95
+ Quick View